indy_bot.jpg

Best Sandwich
2019, 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015, 2014, 2012, 2011, 2010

Durham_mag_BOD.PNG

Best Sandwich
2019, 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015, 2014, 2013

Awards and Mentions 😍

Paninis with ingredients like farm egg, taleggio and chives have secured Toast just about every local best-sandwich award for the past decade.

—Ian Douglass, CurEat (CurEaters’ 10 Favorite Durham Restaurants of 2019)

Owners Billy and Kelli Cotter turn out inventive crostini (one is topped with shrimp and radicchio).

—Kaitlyn Goalen, Food & Wine (Durham, North Carolina's Five Points Intersection)

This joint is a sandwich Mecca. Hot or cold, open faced or smashed in a Panini maker, Toast basically has it all.

—Kristina Held, The Local Palate (It's Sammie Time - A Southern Sandwich Round Up)

Daily specials are driven by what Mr. Cotter finds at local farmers’ markets. During my visit, those selections included fantastic two-bite crostini topped with a creamy mix of avocado, lemon and Grana Padano cheese, and a perfectly crisp panino with fresh asparagus, truffled cheese and fluffy, bright yellow egg, a colorful combination of contrasting textures.

—Ingrid K. Williams, New York Times (Durham Dining: Pies, Panini and Barbecue)

Toast feels like the kind of restaurant we should have in Virginia-Highland but don't: a stylish little cafe that serves fresh, creative and quickly prepared food with panache.

—Bill Addison, Atlanta Magazine (Three Trips to Savor: The Triangle)

The bread was a crunchy, olive oil-glossed beauty with perfect grill marks, and the slices of sausage were large, sweet, porky, and studded with fennel.

—Carrie Vasios, Serious Eats (Sandwich a Day: Rapini and Sweet Italian Sausage Panini at Toast in Durham, NC)
—Elizabeth Shestak, IndyWeek.com (Coming to terms with ricotta; plus, Toast's recipe)
New York Magazine (Elevate lunch at Toast, a paninoteca that serves its Italian-style sandwiches.)
—Mark Petko, Spoonfed (Simplicity and heart. That is what I witnessed at Toast Paninoteca in Durham.)